- Powerfan5000, on 10/30/2008, -73/+53These were the worst episodes in the entire history of South Park. They just drug the same awful Cloverfield bit on for two whole episodes.
- Sornos, on 10/30/2008, -8/+26They really missed an opportunity with Craig. His lines were forgettable this episode while they were the best material of the last. They should've had less Randy. We know he's an idiot.
- FatLoser, on 10/31/2008, -2/+37You can never have too much Randy.
- hubadub, on 10/31/2008, -6/+22couple of the worst episodes from SP in quite a while.
- phuibonhoa, on 10/31/2008, -6/+1I thought these two episodes were some of the betters episodes in a long time. The SP season with the WoW episode was awesome, but last season was so disappointing; I enjoyed these last two episodes more than any episode from last season
- Zachari, on 10/31/2008, -2/+22The fact that you rated these worse than the hockey episode where Stan coaches is sheer lunacy.
- Gregus1032, on 10/31/2008, -0/+8yea, that was by far their worst episode.
by far. - cnot3, on 10/31/2008, -1/+4IDK, I kinda felt bad, but I laughed really hard when the little kid died at the end of that episode.
I think that the episode that aired two weeks ago is high on the running for worse in the series, Cartman used to be my favorite character, in the old episodes he never gave a ***** what people thought of him, now he's just a pussy. - fuzzy889, on 10/31/2008, -1/+2That episode was awesome.
- Gregus1032, on 10/31/2008, -0/+8yea, that was by far their worst episode.
- niteskunk, on 10/31/2008, -0/+7Not awful, not great. This whole season has been kind of "meh" for me, but Season 11 had some pretty epic stuff, so I have high expectations I guess.
- fxu1989, on 10/31/2008, -3/+4Kenny didn't die.
The episode that has the most killing and destruction, and Kenny....didn't die.
D: - Felperus, on 10/31/2008, -0/+4I gotta agree it wasn't my favorite (though I did enjoy the guinea pig costumes), but I was basically reminded that even the worst episodes of South Park are way better than the best episodes of most of the other crap on TV. I didn't cringe at all in the way I do when watching any new episode of The Simpsons. If they had the guinea pigs do more damage and not just sit around...I think it would have been miles better.
"It's a Guinea Bear!"
"No, it's a Guinea Mouse, STUPID"
The redeeming quality of South Park is that even when a ***** episode airs, you can't be sure that next week's won't be brilliant.
The only thing I wish is that they wouldn't do this crap where they divide the season in half and wait half a year to air the second half (like how this is still season 12). - Snoosy, on 10/31/2008, -1/+2Agreed. I didn't laugh once in both episodes. This season has been garbage, except for the breast cancer episode. That one was just amazing.
- danc4498, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1I tend to dislike the shows that require multiple episodes to tell a story. Imagination Land, the Family Guy episodes and this could all have been done much better in a single show (see the hippy music festival episode for an example). Though, I will probably like these more if I saw them multiple times in their entirety, but that will probably not happen as this show only airs in 30 minute segments.
- theSloth, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1"drug"? Really?
- Sornos, on 10/30/2008, -8/+26They really missed an opportunity with Craig. His lines were forgettable this episode while they were the best material of the last. They should've had less Randy. We know he's an idiot.
- andnever, on 10/30/2008, -5/+92i just startled myself
- deathfix, on 10/31/2008, -0/+3Wave at the camera!
- blackbeardtron, on 10/30/2008, -6/+95I laughed my ass off at the whole guinea pig / bee / shark / pirate bit.
- crackerjohn, on 10/31/2008, -10/+1you must be 12 then
- KibblesnBitts, on 10/30/2008, -0/+33There is a negative correlation between epicness of a given South Park episode and the effort put into it
- uallsuck, on 10/31/2008, -3/+1So I guess the WoW episode is just an outlier.
- ConfusedCartman, on 10/31/2008, -0/+5He said "correlation", not "direct relation".
- uallsuck, on 10/31/2008, -3/+1So I guess the WoW episode is just an outlier.
- jbrilliant, on 10/30/2008, -8/+32Brings me back to the pilot I shot at age 13: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-I7Px2IxIRM
- eth3l, on 10/31/2008, -0/+10I cant wait for the sequel!
- mrmount, on 10/30/2008, -2/+9Randy rocks!
- mmittimm, on 10/30/2008, -5/+58Anyone else think this should have been a one parter? I'd rather have seen a fresh episode this week.
- mrbawkbachgawk, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Exactly, totally unnecessary for two episodes. Thinking material may be hard to come by sometimes.
- FishHammer, on 10/31/2008, -1/+3I'd rather have seen a fresh prince episode this week.
- bubbameister33, on 10/31/2008, -2/+11It's a Guinea Bear!!!
- santiago1, on 10/31/2008, -1/+49 I miss Tweak.
- cnot3, on 10/31/2008, -0/+24That's way too much pressure, man. Gah!
- PHJames88, on 10/31/2008, -0/+121. Bring Back Tweak
2. ??????
3. Profit! - Tweak1313, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2Me too :( He was most like me...
- RSS14, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1What happened to Tweak????
- Trekhawk, on 10/31/2008, -3/+64Sure, it didn't have the hard-hitting social or political commentary that makes South Park culturally-relevant, but I l audibly laughed each and every time a new guinea pig costume was revealed.
- Chicken2nite, on 10/31/2008, -5/+1You must've been high on cough syrup
- Chrysalii, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1cute
super cute
- Chrysalii, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1cute
- Chicken2nite, on 10/31/2008, -5/+1You must've been high on cough syrup
- scecilio, on 10/31/2008, -2/+29Not enough material for two episodes. Selective editing of this story into one episode probably would have done the job. Put the deleted scenes on the DVD.
- Zotde75, on 10/31/2008, -4/+4I am so...startled...
- RoboCafaz, on 10/31/2008, -2/+6I thought they were talking about Italians the whole episode. :(
- winkdtm, on 10/31/2008, -11/+16waste of two weeks
- gdeanu, on 10/31/2008, -11/+26episode was hellaweak
- JeffNothing, on 10/31/2008, -0/+9I think you mean Halloween. Oh wait...
- Pramma, on 10/31/2008, -10/+20Easily one of the stupidest South Parks ever.
- rdvon, on 10/31/2008, -1/+2IT'S A GUINEA BEE!!!!
- d0nkeym0nkey, on 10/31/2008, -3/+39It certainly is no ManBearPig...
- userperson, on 10/31/2008, -0/+3Aside of Imaginationland appearance, and making fun of Al Gore in general,
the original ManBearPig episode wasn't all that great.
Not their best, but I thought the Craig business was awesome. - ConeBone6t9, on 10/31/2008, -1/+1no one takes me cereal!
- userperson, on 10/31/2008, -0/+3Aside of Imaginationland appearance, and making fun of Al Gore in general,
- fuzionmuse, on 10/31/2008, -3/+7On Comedy Central now. Well, kinda.... At least here.
Say hi to your mother for me, ok? - MetalGear7, on 10/31/2008, -22/+3
- fucknuggets, on 10/31/2008, -2/+6moar like gears of gay am i right
- vagrantwade, on 10/31/2008, -2/+2YOU ARE WRONG SIR
- vagrantwade, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2So you are saying it won't have gay little sack puppets? Well ***** then I'm sold!
- fucknuggets, on 10/31/2008, -2/+6moar like gears of gay am i right
- tofslie, on 10/31/2008, -2/+7All hail Craig
- offcenter, on 10/31/2008, -5/+1Blogspam. False link to the SouthPark site at the bottom of the page.
- tehsilentcircus, on 10/31/2008, -4/+15This ***** was hilarious. Though I have to agree, its no ManBearPig, but ***** great.South Park is going to reign over all other cartoons for a very long ***** time. (I love Family Guy and all that too, but come on...) South Park was offensive before the idea of family guy even popped into mcfarlane's head. Deal with it
- asleepy0, on 10/31/2008, -6/+17I don't get all the hate for this episode, I enjoyed it a lot.
- cnot3, on 10/31/2008, -4/+10The new episodes are ***** compared to the first half a dozen seasons, but it's still one of the best shows on television, since most TV sucks ass.
I bet the commentary is funnier than the episode. If theres one reason to buy the DVDs its the commentary by Matt and Trey, that are ***** hilarious. - indubitably, on 10/31/2008, -6/+8were these episodes intentionally unfunny? was that the joke?
- DLit, on 10/31/2008, -1/+13I AM SOOO STARTLED
- bloodqc, on 10/31/2008, -10/+2I love South Park but why a link every week? The episodes are not so good so far...
- Pramma, on 10/31/2008, -0/+43Anyone else disappointed they didn't touch the election even on the last Wednesday before the election?
- floridiot2, on 10/31/2008, -1/+6SIMPSON'S DID IT
- financedude2, on 10/31/2008, -0/+3They'll run a giant douche and turd sandwich episode again
- mmmunaf, on 10/31/2008, -10/+7Man, SP is really disappointing this season. I think Trey is tapped out. He needs a new muse, fast.
- Gregus1032, on 10/31/2008, -1/+17was anyone else waiting for a Guinea Manbearpig?
- d0nkeym0nkey, on 10/31/2008, -1/+3I was and I am super duper cereal.
- whataSAMF, on 11/28/2008, -1/+1with milk?
- tgulden, on 10/31/2008, -2/+5Okay, so I'm watching South Park on TV, it's on commercial. I hit play on the video, and then the show comes back from break. The two are perfectly in sync. It was kinda nuts. Dumb luck is cool like that. (Phenomenon occurred at approx. 11:25 Central Daylight)
- polypropglop, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Are you positive?
- ShadowXII, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2I'm not just positive
I'm HIV sure
Wait...
- ShadowXII, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2I'm not just positive
- polypropglop, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Are you positive?
- samsonthesaxman, on 10/31/2008, -1/+3Well I enjoyed it
And now there is lightning shooting out from my eyes- cmscott, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2sparks, yo.
- horsevet, on 10/31/2008, -1/+0And you're William Wallace! Or was that from the other end?
Even the best can't please everyone all the time!
- sibos, on 10/31/2008, -1/+3ARRRGGG!! CURSE YE, CRAIG!!!!!!!!
- bunnyman1, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2Robots don't say "ye!"
- Regulator980, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2Counter Argument:
http://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/103797 - swatch60, on 10/31/2008, -1/+4Craig's characterization was fantastic. The rest of the episode(s), not so much.
- AtleticoMadrid, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Its funny that craig describes all the people hating on Southpark and it looks like they didn't realize it.
- politik192, on 10/31/2008, -0/+4remember when Craig only was known for randomly flipping people off?
- enivid, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Yeah, he used to be cool.
- rainydaywoman, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Cuuute....
- bcruss24, on 10/31/2008, -2/+1I want one of those costumes that the Guinea Pig has!!!!
- tumples, on 10/31/2008, -0/+13I thought these two episodes were really funny. I didn't think it would gather so much dislike as it did.
- bagboyrebel, on 10/31/2008, -0/+5When a show get's old, even an awesome show like Southpark, it becomes cool to hate it no matter what.
- josephthered, on 10/31/2008, -0/+4I completely agree. I hate when people rag on things just because it's "cool." God forbid they admit they liked something when it's cool to make fun of it.
- bagboyrebel, on 10/31/2008, -0/+5When a show get's old, even an awesome show like Southpark, it becomes cool to hate it no matter what.
- heccubus, on 10/31/2008, -0/+6I enjoyed the episode quite I bit. I sort of took Craig's criticizing the boys for their unwavering desire to explore and do things that are bound to lead to trouble as Parker and Stone once again beating critics to the punch by making fun of the show's occasional predictability themselves.
- SwedishNinja, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Oh man, all my hamsters escaped and fell into the sump pump too! None of them drowned, though, but that thing was like a trap for escaped hansters.
- socoolisme, on 10/31/2008, -5/+5Cloverfield FTW
- Dested, on 10/31/2008, -1/+9CLOVERFIELD FTL
- socoolisme, on 10/31/2008, -1/+1Dested GFY
- Dested, on 10/31/2008, -1/+9CLOVERFIELD FTL
- JHB800, on 10/31/2008, -0/+4Should have been a one-part episode, but it was a great episode. It was complete and utter nonsense, which was refreshing. These types of episodes are what made South Park great in the first place (before they started taking on current issues), so it was great to see them go back to it.
The highlights of the episodes were the Guinea Pirate and Guinea Saurus Rex. - manderbruin, on 10/31/2008, -1/+3south park hasn't been decent since season 8 but this was really hilarious. Much needed belly laugh!!!
Guinea Bees! - mltvcocktail, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1South Park seems to be doing these "events" every season since 10. First there was Go God Go, then last year's amazing "Imagationland" trilogy. This one was no where near as good as either of those but it was still fun. Guinea Pirate!
- Gregus1032, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1Imaginationland was better than amazing.
- random12345, on 11/16/2008, -1/+1I was very disappointed with the recent South Park seasons/episodes. But this past episode (not the 1st half from last week... that was horrible) was great. The whole guinea pig thing was classic South Park- no real political agenda or anything... just a downright funny/childish/silly show... which is not bad at all.
- mkNix, on 10/31/2008, -1/+1I didnt enjoy my dinner while watching these two episodes. Thats how i feel about them.
- crackerjohn, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1same here
- grantmoore3d, on 10/31/2008, -0/+2Awww... I forgot to put a tape in it.
- rdvon, on 10/31/2008, -0/+4I thought these episodes were amazing, I wouldn't rank them at the top of my list... but you can't not laugh at Guinea pigs attacking cities dressed up as animals.
Craig was awesome too.- javiero, on 10/31/2008, -0/+0Lemmiwings would've been much much better
- kierskoe, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1You must be go team southpark number one fan USA 100%!
Lick my battery! - rdvon, on 11/02/2008, -0/+1That's what she said.
- kierskoe, on 11/19/2008, -0/+1She didnt not say that....
- kierskoe, on 10/31/2008, -0/+1You must be go team southpark number one fan USA 100%!
- javiero, on 10/31/2008, -0/+0Lemmiwings would've been much much better
- javiero, on 10/31/2008, -2/+0So I came in here thinking I was the onlyone commenting about not liking this ep. but im glad Im not crazy. I think is funny how sometimes the plot goes completely crazy, like aliens snorting coke and having sex, or the taco that farts icecream (that was hilarious nonsense) but this is just not that funny.. the plot might ve had much more potential if it was LEMMIWINGS (Hail to his majesty Gerbil King!! ) instead of random guinea pigs...
Still southpark kicks ass, but this was too much of not so fun material, specially for two entire eps, and specially after a hillarious season opener. -
Show 51 - 62 of 62 discussions



What is Digg?
Check out the new & improved